CarMax
Used car dealer near Amherst, New York — Updated September 2026
Reviews Across the Web
SearchRush Reviews
Real reviews from the SearchRush community
No reviews yet — be the first to review CarMax
Write the first review
About CarMax
AI summaryCarMax is a highly rated used car dealer in Amherst, New York. Situated on Niagara Falls Blvd, the facility is recognized for its extensive inventory of certified pre-owned vehicles and a transparent appraisal process that provides immediate cash offers for trade-ins. The location maintains a 4.4-star rating based on over 650 reviews, with customers frequently citing the streamlined financing department and the availability of 24-hour test drives. This dealership serves the greater Erie County area by offering both onsite sales and home delivery options.
- Monday
- 11AM – 8PM
- Tuesday
- 11AM – 8PM
- Wednesday
- 11AM – 8PM
- Thursday
- 11AM – 8PM
- Friday
- 11AM – 8PM
- Saturday
- 9AM – 7PM
- Sunday
- Closed
Best time to visit
- Weekday afternoons (2–5 PM) are typically the quietest times to visit
- Friday and Saturday evenings (6–9 PM) tend to be the busiest
Based on typical patterns for this category and posted hours.
Compare nearby Used car dealer in Amherst
How CarMax stacks up against similar nearby options.
| Name | Rating | Reviews | Price | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Northtown Automotive Companies | 4.2 | 553 | — | 2.1 mi |
| Northtown Kia | 4.8 | 4,888 | — | 2.4 mi |
| Spitzer Chevrolet Amherst | 4.6 | 1,753 | — | 205.6 mi |
Have you visited CarMax?
Share your experience and help other locals find CarMax.
Frequently Asked Questions about CarMax
What are the hours for CarMax in Amherst?
CarMax in Amherst is open Monday: 11AM – 8PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 8PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 8PM. Thursday: 11AM – 8PM. Friday: 11AM – 8PM. Saturday: 9AM – 7PM. Sunday: Closed.
How much does CarMax charge for a Used car dealer?
CarMax is in the $$ price range. For exact Used car dealer pricing, call +1716-243-4850 or visit https://www.carmax.com/stores/6059?utm_source=SEO_Local&utm_medium=SEO_Local_Snack_Pack&utm_campaign=SEO_NY&utm_content=SEO_Amherst&utm_term=6059.
Is CarMax in Amherst good?
CarMax has a 4.4-star rating based on 672 verified Google reviews in Amherst, making it one of the better-rated used car dealer options in Amherst.
Does CarMax accept walk-ins?
Walk-in policy varies. Call +1716-243-4850 to confirm availability.
Where is CarMax located in Amherst?
CarMax is located at 1881 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, New York, 14228. Use the map above or click Get Directions for turn-by-turn navigation.
Where is CarMax located?
CarMax is located at 1881 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, New York, 14228.
What are the hours at CarMax?
Monday: 11AM – 8PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 8PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 8PM. Thursday: 11AM – 8PM. Friday: 11AM – 8PM. Saturday: 9AM – 7PM. Sunday: Closed
What is the phone number for CarMax?
+1716-243-4850
What are the prices at CarMax?
CarMax is in the $$ price range.
What is CarMax's Google rating?
CarMax in Amherst, New York has a 4.4-star rating based on 672 Google reviews.
People also searched for
672 Google reviews·Unclaimed listing
Claim this business to unlock review syndication →Claim CarMax free to automatically publish your 5-star reviews across 20+ platforms — building authority everywhere customers look.
Other CarMax locations
More CarMax locations across different cities. Each location has its own verified reviews and hours.
Explore more around CarMax
Discover other businesses and searches in Amherst
Browse Nearby
Other Used car dealer nearby
Find more used car dealers near CarMax →
People found CarMax by searching for
Want reviews like this working for your business?
SearchRush syndicates your 5-star Google reviews to 20+ platforms automatically.
Start Growing For Free