Claim this business →
SearchRush
Mexican · Mexican restaurant · Grill · Restaurant$$

El Maguey Grill

Mexican near Goshen, Indiana — Updated October 2026

4.3· 1,813 Google reviews
· Goshen, Indiana Open now · Closes 10PM Verified on Google📍 Unclaimed listing · Is this your business? Claim it free — we'll call to verify →
Book online
Call Directions Menu Website
Been here? Share your experience
Be the first to review El Maguey Grill on SearchRush
Write a Review

Reviews Across the Web

Sourced from Google Knowledge Panel
Verified
Google
4.3
1,813 reviews
Combined reputation score: 4.3 / 5.0 across 1 platform and 1,813 total reviews

SearchRush Reviews

Real reviews from the SearchRush community

No reviews yet — be the first to review El Maguey Grill

Write the first review
El Maguey Grill photo 1El Maguey Grill photo 2El Maguey Grill photo 3

About El Maguey Grill

AI summary

El Maguey Grill is a highly-rated Mexican restaurant in Goshen, Indiana. Located on Parkway Avenue, the establishment holds a 4.3-star rating based on over 1,700 customer reviews and is recognized for its authentic menu items including street tacos, fajitas, and fresh chips with salsa. The restaurant provides a casual dining atmosphere with options for both sit-down service and takeout. Patrons frequently note the efficiency of the service and the consistent quality of the traditional Mexican cuisine in the Goshen area.

Best for
Business lunch
Hours
Monday
11AM – 9PM
Tuesday
11AM – 10PM
Wednesday
11AM – 10PM
Thursday
11AM – 10PM
Friday
11AM – 10PM
Saturday
11AM – 10PM
Sunday
11AM – 9PM

Atmosphere & Amenities

What you can expect at El Maguey Grill.

Service options: Onsite Services · Takeout · Serves Dine In · Fast Service · Serves Beer Notable · Serves Cocktails Notable · Serves Dessert Notable · Local Specialty · Serves Lunch Popular · Serves Dinner Popular · Suitable For Solo Dining · Serves Alcohol · Serves Beer · Serves Cocktails · Serves Coffee · Serves Comfort Food · Serves Happy Hour Drinks · Serves Liquor · Private Dining Room · Quick Bite · Serves Small Plates · Serves Vegetarian · Serves Wine · Serves Lunch
Verified on Google
4.3
· 1,813 Google reviews
View on Google Maps

Best time to visit

  • Weekday afternoons (2–5 PM) are typically the quietest times to visit
  • Friday and Saturday evenings (6–9 PM) tend to be the busiest
  • Sunday brunch hours are popular — arrive early for shorter waits

Based on typical patterns for this category and posted hours.

Compare nearby Mexican in Goshen

How El Maguey Grill stacks up against similar nearby options.

NameRatingReviewsPriceDistance
Chipotle Mexican Grill3.4341—4.4 mi
La Botana Food truck5.08—5.0 mi
San Jose Supermarket4.2169—5.7 mi
Cemitas Poblanas Mexican Resturant4.722—6.1 mi

Have you visited El Maguey Grill?

Share your experience and help other locals find El Maguey Grill.

Write a SearchRush Review →

Frequently Asked Questions about El Maguey Grill

What are the hours for El Maguey Grill in Goshen?

El Maguey Grill in Goshen is open Monday: 11AM – 9PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 10PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 10PM. Thursday: 11AM – 10PM. Friday: 11AM – 10PM. Saturday: 11AM – 10PM. Sunday: 11AM – 9PM.

How much does El Maguey Grill charge for a Mexican?

El Maguey Grill is in the $$ price range. For exact Mexican pricing, call +1574-522-1100 or visit http://www.elmagueygrillelkhart.com/.

Is El Maguey Grill in Goshen good?

El Maguey Grill has a 4.3-star rating based on 1,813 verified Google reviews in Goshen, making it one of the better-rated mexican options in Goshen.

Does El Maguey Grill accept walk-ins?

El Maguey Grill primarily operates by appointment. Book online to secure a time slot.

Where is El Maguey Grill located in Goshen?

El Maguey Grill is located at 56028 Parkway Ave A, Goshen, Indiana, 46528. Use the map above or click Get Directions for turn-by-turn navigation.

Where is El Maguey Grill located?

El Maguey Grill is located at 56028 Parkway Ave A, Goshen, Indiana, 46528.

What are the hours at El Maguey Grill?

Monday: 11AM – 9PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 10PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 10PM. Thursday: 11AM – 10PM. Friday: 11AM – 10PM. Saturday: 11AM – 10PM. Sunday: 11AM – 9PM

What is the phone number for El Maguey Grill?

+1574-522-1100

What are the prices at El Maguey Grill?

El Maguey Grill is in the $$ price range.

What is El Maguey Grill's Google rating?

El Maguey Grill in Goshen, Indiana has a 4.3-star rating based on 1,813 Google reviews.

People also searched for

Mexican near me Mexican Goshen Best mexicans in Goshen Mexican INDIANA Top-rated mexican Goshen

1,813 Google reviews·Unclaimed listing

Claim this business to unlock review syndication →

Claim El Maguey Grill free to automatically publish your 5-star reviews across 20+ platforms — building authority everywhere customers look.

Other El Maguey Grill locations

More El Maguey Grill locations across different cities. Each location has its own verified reviews and hours.

J
Jasper, Indiana
4.5· 669 reviews

Explore more around El Maguey Grill

Discover other businesses and searches in Goshen

Want reviews like this working for your business?

SearchRush syndicates your 5-star Google reviews to 20+ platforms automatically.

Start Growing For Free