El Maguey Grill
Mexican near Jasper, Indiana — Updated September 2026
Reviews Across the Web
SearchRush Reviews
Real reviews from the SearchRush community
No reviews yet — be the first to review El Maguey Grill
Write the first review
About El Maguey Grill
AI summaryEl Maguey Grill is a highly-rated Mexican restaurant in Jasper, Indiana, maintaining a 4.5-star rating across more than 600 customer reviews. Located on North Newton Street, this mid-range establishment is noted for its extensive menu of traditional dishes, including street tacos, sizzling fajitas, and house-made salsa. The restaurant provides a casual dining atmosphere with full table service and is frequently cited for its efficient turnaround times and consistent food quality. Visitors often highlight the variety of their specialty margaritas and authentic appetizers available for both dine-in and takeout.
- Monday
- 11AM – 10PM
- Tuesday
- 11AM – 10PM
- Wednesday
- 11AM – 10PM
- Thursday
- 11AM – 10PM
- Friday
- 11AM – 10:30PM
- Saturday
- 11AM – 10:30PM
- Sunday
- 11AM – 9PM
Atmosphere & Amenities
What you can expect at El Maguey Grill.
Best time to visit
- Weekday afternoons (2–5 PM) are typically the quietest times to visit
- Friday and Saturday evenings (6–9 PM) tend to be the busiest
- Sunday brunch hours are popular — arrive early for shorter waits
Based on typical patterns for this category and posted hours.
Compare nearby Mexican in Jasper
How El Maguey Grill stacks up against similar nearby options.
| Name | Rating | Reviews | Price | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mi Jalisco Mexican Restaurant | 4.6 | 630 | $$ | 0.3 mi |
| Cabos San Lucas | 4.4 | 1,792 | $$ | 317.1 mi |
| La Famila Mexican Restaurant | 4.7 | 450 | — | 416.9 mi |
Have you visited El Maguey Grill?
Share your experience and help other locals find El Maguey Grill.
Frequently Asked Questions about El Maguey Grill
What are the hours for El Maguey Grill in Jasper?
El Maguey Grill in Jasper is open Monday: 11AM – 10PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 10PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 10PM. Thursday: 11AM – 10PM. Friday: 11AM – 10:30PM. Saturday: 11AM – 10:30PM. Sunday: 11AM – 9PM.
How much does El Maguey Grill charge for a Mexican?
El Maguey Grill is in the $$ price range. For exact Mexican pricing, call +1812-481-1799 or visit https://www.elmagueygrilljasper.com/.
Is El Maguey Grill in Jasper good?
El Maguey Grill has a 4.5-star rating based on 669 verified Google reviews in Jasper, making it one of the better-rated mexican options in Jasper.
Does El Maguey Grill accept walk-ins?
El Maguey Grill primarily operates by appointment. Book online to secure a time slot.
Where is El Maguey Grill located in Jasper?
El Maguey Grill is located at 3570 N Newton St, Jasper, Indiana, 47546. Use the map above or click Get Directions for turn-by-turn navigation.
Where is El Maguey Grill located?
El Maguey Grill is located at 3570 N Newton St, Jasper, Indiana, 47546.
What are the hours at El Maguey Grill?
Monday: 11AM – 10PM. Tuesday: 11AM – 10PM. Wednesday: 11AM – 10PM. Thursday: 11AM – 10PM. Friday: 11AM – 10:30PM. Saturday: 11AM – 10:30PM. Sunday: 11AM – 9PM
What is the phone number for El Maguey Grill?
+1812-481-1799
What are the prices at El Maguey Grill?
El Maguey Grill is in the $$ price range.
What is El Maguey Grill's Google rating?
El Maguey Grill in Jasper, Indiana has a 4.5-star rating based on 669 Google reviews.
People also searched for
669 Google reviews·Unclaimed listing
Claim this business to unlock review syndication →Claim El Maguey Grill free to automatically publish your 5-star reviews across 20+ platforms — building authority everywhere customers look.
Other El Maguey Grill locations
More El Maguey Grill locations across different cities. Each location has its own verified reviews and hours.
Explore more around El Maguey Grill
Discover other businesses and searches in Jasper
Browse Nearby
People found El Maguey Grill by searching for
Related searches in Jasper, Indiana
Want reviews like this working for your business?
SearchRush syndicates your 5-star Google reviews to 20+ platforms automatically.
Start Growing For Free